Monday, 7 May 2018

Part 2 Mercury

There is no needs for everyone to have same opportunity in order to achieve the American Dream. Instead, people who work harder should have more chance to achieve themselves. In this case, people who have a similar dream may work together and share their experience. Therefore, these people will stay together and build their own community. These community may base on friendship, same purpose or even money in order achieve their same dream.

According to the Great Gatsby, Nick had a rich family which could offer him help. However, he still left his home and came to West Egg for his own purpose. In this story, Nick did not have a great dream but just wanted to work by himself in order to survive. He was asked for help by Gatsby when they knew each other, which means he could ask for any resource include money or network to Gatsby at that moment. However, he did nothing but helped Gatsby by inviting Daisy to his house because he saw Gatsby as his friend.

Although Gatsby became extremely rich in serval years, he still could not achieve his dream alone. As a result, he has to depend on Nick so that he can get closer to Daisy. He tried to build his relationship to Nick by money because he believes that money can solve any problems. Meanwhile, Nick was trying to build his community to Gatsby by friendship. Nick left his home and began his new life as well as Gatsby. Although he was very poor compare to people around him, Nick refused the financial help from Gatsby because he wanted to build a relation base on friendship instead of money. However, after he stayed with Gatsby and other rich people. He lost his individuality and indulged in money. In this case, Nick has to depend on Gatsby in order to enjoy the benefit of money. At this moment, Nick has already lost his community to Gatsby as their relationship is no longer base on friendship. And Nick was not a rich person at all, and the relation between Nick and Gatsby is base on Daisy. Which means as soon as Gatsby achieve his dream, Nick will become meaningless to him. As Nick experience the luxury life, it will be hard for him to go back to his normal life without Gatsby. For Gatsby, he build his community to people by money. It seems that he is succeed as so many people admire him and join his party. But in fact, people only go to Gatsby's party for resource instead of Gatsby himself. As soon as Gatsby no longer offer his resource to public, no one will be close to him.

Compare to the news, editor lists top 10 cities where have more opportunities for people to achieve the American Dream. Actually, people from the Great Gatsby have already stayed together for their own purpose. As a result, the cities which rich people gather together became richer and more prosperous that other cities. In the end, people who born in a poor city will almost have no chance to achieve the American Dream because they have no ability to move out.







Sunday, 6 May 2018

Part 2 Grace(Yaoqing) Zhang Different people to achieve the same American dream

From my personal perspective, the American dream is like Maslow's hierarchy of needs, which means people's life goals vary from each other when they stay at different levels. People came from different families, different societies that make them unique, and the degrees of difficulty in realizing their "American dream" are various too. Moreover, even if people have the same life goal, the same desire, they cannot spend the same effort to achieve their goals because they have different backgrounds and experiences. It could only be equal for everyone to realize their "American dream" if people live in an ideal world where everything happened under a most favorable circumstance; however, the fact is opposite.

In the book "The Great Gatsby," Daisy and Myrtle have the same "American dream" which is to marry a rich man and enjoy life. They both are quite materialistic and self-interested women. In chapter 4, the description of Daisy and Tom's wedding is a good demonstration. "In June she married Tom Buchanan of Chicago, with more pomp and circumstance than Louisville ever knew before. He came down with a hundred people in four private cars and hired a whole floor of the Muhlbach Hotel, and the day before the wedding he gave her a string of pearls valued at three hundred and fifty thousand dollars." In chapter 2, the description of Myrtle, when she saw Tom, can also show her desire to marry a rich man too. "She smiled slowly and, walking through her husband as if he were a ghost, shook hands with Tom, looking him flush in the eye." She does not pay any attention to her husband because he is very poor.

This book clearly shows that American dream cannot be achieved equally as everyone is unique. Daisy can fulfill her American dream because she is old money and she can marry to Tom while Myrtle cannot because she has low social status. When Daisy was young, she loved Gatsby without thinking about the difference in social standing between her and Gatsby. Before her wedding, Daisy received a letter from Gatsby and nearly wanted to escape the marriage. However, she changed her mind at last, which can illustrate two things. Firstly, as old money, Daisy must follow the tradition and gave up who she really loved. Secondly, as a woman, Daisy knows what she wants, an extravagant life with abundant materials. The description of her wedding can show how rich Tom is and the countless wealth and luxury goods Tom can bring to her. She becomes more and more mature when she is getting elder, and she realizes the effect of blood which comes from old money. Daisy can follow the tradition naturally and find her happiness when owning so much. She even knows that her husband is cheating on her, but she does not want to leave him because of the vast amount of money Tom owns and his high social status.
“了不起的盖茨比 黛西”的图片搜索结果
Daisy in the party

On the contrary, it is impossible for Myrtle to achieve her American dream, although as the mistress of Tom, she has tried her best to learn how to act as old money. For example, "Her laughter, her gestures, her assertions became more violently affected moment by moment," which shows that her personality and behavior have changed because of the money.  She treats her husband like a ghost because he is quite weak and poor, and she is looking forward to being loved by Tom, a wealthy man forever. However, when she said Daisy's name, she was beaten by Tom because she is in low social class and does not have the right to say Daisy's name. The fact that Tom lets her be his mistress is because it is convenient to get rid of a poor person. Thus her American dream will never become true.

相关图片
The scene when Myrtle sees Tom
According to the video"How economic inequality harms societies" by Richard Wilkinson, it is clear that in the real world people still do not entirely have the equality when they are in different societies. The quality of life, the level of education, the quality of environment all influence people's opportunity to arrive their life goals. Therefore, people should make awareness of the fact that it is still a little unequal in the real world and we should make our effort to make the "American dream" equal for everyone to achieve in the future.

I choose Sorenson's part 2 to do the comment.


Part 2 Vito(Shuren)Wang

Part 2

The American dream in part 1 is regarded as a yearning to transform people's spiritual pursuit into material consumption. It means that people want to show their value to the society by consuming. It is also reflected in The Great Gatsby. The book shows the hypocrisy and materialism of the upper class and hints at their economic decline after the boom of the 1920s. Everyone in the book loves money, being famous and having a rich life is their American Dream, which is consumerist.
In the story, when Daisy found that Gatsby is not one of the“old money”and he is absolutely one of the“new money”, she felt so uncomfortable that she made a car accident on their way back. which lead the death of Myrtle Wilson. Disillusioned Daisy imputed the car accident to Gatsby with Tom.
Daisy was born in a rich family so that she has experienced rich life. She needs to be one of the“old money” to realize her American Dream, which means the only thing she needs is to have an aristocratic temperament. Compared to the“old money”, the“new money” is as rich as them, what they lacked is noble aesthetics. Although Gatsby has earned a lot of money,  his flamboyant parties disgust Daisy. Gatsby always stands at the balcony of the third floor, with opening arms. He wants to hug the light tower which is shining in green lights. After World War I, advertisements were very popular, what people want to do is go shopping, go consuming. Rich people had nothing to do except holding huge parties. At this time, people who think they are noble tried to be sharply demarcated from these rich people. They thought they have noble blood and they are well educated. No more goods to buy, these rich people were consuming their reputation as a way of realizing American Dream. The hypocrisy of the “old money” is that they think one who inherited the money from his family is a tradition, they ignore individual efforts. 
Gatsby tried to one of the “old money” but he can never realize his American Dream because he has no reputation to consume when comparing to the “old money” like Tom.
To some of the rich people, what they want is not just money but also reputation, which has already been metamorphic to others. For those who are upstart, they can never be the people who are distinguished as the American Dream.

I did comments on Bill's work.

Part 2 Victor Yang

From my point of view, the American Dream is an idealistic belief that everyone is able to grasp equal opportunity to succeed by working assiduously, regardless of other social factors such as gender and skin color. But for lower class, the American dream is just a hopeful assumption in reality. Like Brazilian women, they forfeit certain rights caused by people’s discrimination. Therefore, Brazilian women begin to fight for gaining their rights, but their effort is under great pressure created by people’s stereotype to women. The unattainability of feminism in society is a reflection of the hypocrisy of the American dream. In "The Great Gatsby”,  I believe that neither Gatsby nor Daisy could achieve the American dream because they chose to indulge in the illusion of a fantasy world created by society and show no desire to face the cruel side of American Dream.

                                            Gatsby, a money pursuer, demonstrates no love to woman

For Gatsby, he misunderstands the American dream as a satisfaction of wealth. Besides, his romantic relationship with Daisy mix with money. He regards Daisy as a commercialization goods instead of true lover, and a representative of his prestigious status, just because she is old money. The deliberate ignorance to feminism become a main trigger for the tragedy of his love. For example, Gatsby thinks Daisy “her voice is full of money”. Gatsby regards his love for Daisy as a desire for wealth. The ultimate purpose of Gatsby holding party and approaching Nick is to regain Daisy’s love, but he cannot distinguish from what is true love and  material pursuit. The ignorance of the government undoubtedly creates an illusion for Gatsby's concept of money and love, which make him blindly worship the process of realizing American Dream, but blur the concept about equality of gender and race. Although Gatsby respects Daisy, he ignores the gender equality in dealing with Daisy, and the sense of male supremacy has led him to strip off Daisy’s right to make choice. Therefore, for Americans like New Money Gatsby, the gorgeous dream in reality is equivalent to money and social status.

                                          Daisy, old money, a selfish woman who care material much


For Daisy, the new woman, Her failure of the American dream is due to her obsession with material wealth and selfishness. I mentioned in Part 1, the loss of women’s gender equality results in women’s failure to successfully achieve the American dream. For Brazilian women, their abortion right has striped off by constitutional amendment, no one in society cares much about their voice about abortion. Similarly, Daisy’ right to choose has deprived by male, she acts as a tool to fulfill male’s vanity.  For instance, Although Daisy gains ample wealth from Tom, she still endures Tom’s indifferent treatment and never receive respect at all.His attitude makes Daisy feel painful about her life. Besides, Daisy only care about Gatsby’s money instead of truly caring him, so she lets Gatsby take the responsibility for accidental death of Myrtle. Her selfishness and female’s social status are important factors that make her unable to realize the American Dream.

In my opinion, I think that society needs some reformations, like advertising the awareness to prohibit the racial discrimination, and claiming that male and female are equal. Every new woman should be given equal rights in terms of the equality between social statuses so that everyone is available and equal to achieve the American Dream. Otherwise, not only the women, the rest of the American Dream pursuers will be destroyed by the hypocrisy of the reality.















Part 2-charlie(zhihan zhang)- A superficial honesty


  During the Roaring Twenties, social attitudes changed dramatically in 1920s because of World War one, increased wealth and prohibition. In this way, my opinion is that the reason why the American Dream is equal to everyone because I strongly believe that the success always depends on my passion and belief to the dream. Most successful people are rich or famous because they spend their time on what they passion about or they feeling that something is definitely exists in their inner heart. Therefore, everyone is equal because everyone starts at the same point and the success depends on whether you work harder or give up.

  In fact, the story can be seen as a tragic love story on the surface, but it’s most commonly understand as a pessimistic critique of the American dream. Nick is one of my favorite character in the novel because he gives me an overall perspective of the lives of those who reach for the American dream, building up an opinion about it. Nick himself is very striving for something because he wants to be tolerant and reliable. The reason I choose Nick because he also has a tough life in the beginning in the novel and this relates to my previous ideas in part one which tells about only if you know what you are seeking for and you will gain what you want in the end. Nick's passion is taken away from others because even he works so hard for his dream and he still looses them in the end. Everything he did is for himself especially when he finds out that money is no longer the most important thing in his life. And this is why when Nick has his own passion about life and he does show his improvements after his faher's warning before he goes in to the society. The only difference is that Nick fights for his dream to make his own fortune. Gatsby and Nick are both dishonest who pretends to be honest to readers because they want to show the positive side of their lifestyle. However, I do think Nick achieves the dream and Gatsby does not. Nick learned that money does not mean success, it only demonstrates an unfilled American Dream. But Gatsby believes that the past can be repeated by buying time which is impossible and contradictory. However, the only thing need to change is that Gatsby needs to realize that the power of wealthy can not get what he wants and he should face the past.

  In my younger and more vulnerable years my father gave me some advice that I‘ve been turning over in my mind ever since. 'whenever you feel like criticizing anyone,' he told me,'just remember that all the people in this world haven't had the advantages that you've had.' The reason I use this quotation to prove my American dream because it establishes Nick as a thoughtful and judgemental character in the novel. Nick tells about his background because he wants to have the trust between the reader. Although some people think that Nick is a liar because he lies many times in the novel. One of the most memoriable thing for him is that he acts as a thoughtful role who gives me a perspective of the lives and life. Therefore, Nick is the only person who can prove my American Dream because he is a outsider of what he seen in Gatsby's story and the reality does show that the American Dream is equal to everyone because the success always depends on your passion and belief to the dream. In my personal view of American Dream, one of the similarity between Gatsby and Nick is the location of their establishment where they are neighborhood. And both of them are hard working people in search of the American Dream. The only difference from anyone else is that Nick acts as a narrator in the novel and he actually is the main character in the story all the time. Gatsby and Nick connects to the American Dream of hard working because they both are looking for more money. 


  Compare to the media example in part 1 which tells about the reality of American Dream. Both of them mention about that people need to work harder more than others in a competitive society in order to have a better future. Therefore, Nick did it when he goes to the society and he uses his special skills to prove his life quality. When he reaches the peak of passion and the best behaviour that he has ever had in his life and then he achieves his success lastly.















part2 Lynn

bank loans
Part 2 
American dream advocate that all men have certain inalienable right including ‘life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.’ which can be regarded as people's yearning for a better life and pursuit. It can also be regarded as the pursuit of material enjoyment. The American dream only stays in material pursuit and does not rise to the spiritual level. So,I think people use American dream to express them ambition and desire. People can't get real happiness and freedom from it. 

 In the great Gatsby,Gatsby can be regarded as the representative of the pursuit of the American dream. Gatsby’s pursuit of the American dream can be seen as his pursuit of Daisy. Gatsby wanted to break the limits of his lineage, and he sought the freedom, life and happiness of the American dream. In the novel, Gatsby pursues the American dream as Daisy. Daisy represents Gatsby’s desire and ambition. Later Gatsby had money and he wanted to reclaim Daisy. Just as people pursue life and happiness in American dreams. Daisy also represents the happy life of Gatsby, the freedom to transcend class and blood restriction, and the high quality of life represented by Daisy. He also wants to use money to break class limits. He even wants money to buy back time and affection. In the process, Gatsby did not get real happiness and freedom. He thought about how to please and chase Daisy every day, but he could not make him happy. At the same time, he was subject to the limits of his lineage. Gatsby did not pursue spiritual freedom. He is confined to matter and past. Gatsby threw a party to invite the old aristocracy to fit in with the old aristocracy. He didn't want to break the class limit. At the same time he was confined to the past, and he wanted to buy back the old days with Daisy.

In the society at that time, people used bank loans to meet their needs in a short time. Loans enable people to satisfy their desires even when their personal abilities are limited. People were pouring money from the Banks to meet the material they couldn't have today. Like a house, a car. This makes people's future life not really happy and free. They worry about how to repay their loans every day. Imprisoned by bank loans.

Ipart3--Lynn's comment for Haley


part 2 Daisy everything is achievable

Gatsby and Daisy
In my opinion, American Dream is that the birth doesn’t determine the future, people can work hard to keep away from the restriction of the background. Because money and social status are achievable if you just work hard and catch chances to make yourselves be wealthier. On the other word, the Old Money and the New Money could get along with each other because they achieve high achievements via different way though. If people work hard and become richer, they can buy whatever they want, even the past, their backgrounds, the education or marriage. Then, they will be as same as the Old Money.

In the book, Gatsby is a kind of person who believes that money can buy everything even fix the past via his hard work to become the Old Money. However, I don’t think he achieves his American Dream via buying social status because no matter where did he live, he still couldn’t move to East Egg, though he was closest to the East Money. He will still fail in nowadays because the background does not only mean a large amount of money but also mean the that their families can provide them more excellent social resources which are easier to get success. For example, even the education which is thought the most possible way to change the class is also a money consumed investment. In order to accept the best education, parents have to spend thousands of money to send their children to private schools. Even these after class tutoring or interest classes are very expensive. It requires the family can provide strong supports so that children can enter top universities.


 Gatsby is the kind of person who strongly believes that money can buy everything and fix the past so that it can seek for social states like the Old Money. For example, he cheated his past that when he introduced his background, he emphasized that he was born in a wealthy family which is closer to the Old Money, and he also lied that he was educated in Oxford. However, the problem is that he was trying to hide his true pats to pretend he was an Old Money instead of really fixing it. On the other hand, he also loved Daisy and he hoped to marry her. So he bought a big house and threw big parties so that it can attract Daisy. In fact, Gatsby didn’t really love Daisy, married Daisy is just another goal to prove his American Dream. If he has an Old Money wife, it means that he becomes a crowd of the Old Money. And he also has a bigger plan about Daisy. For example, he said, “Her voice is full of money”. It confirms that he will use Daisy to get higher goals so that he was crazy to Daisy.


Compare these two thoughts, all of them strongly believe that the birth doesn’t determine the future. And they are working hard to fix the shortage of their background. They are quite similar but in the different process. The family in picture in part I is still seeking for money, but Gatsby has already got a mount of money and he hopes to achieve higher social statues.